St. Peters Cream Stout - This was both of our favorites. With the vanilla ice cream the beer was a perfect compliment. The chocolate was also good but the vanilla was just a tad better
Youn's Luxury Double Chocolate Stout - The idea here was to get a chocolate beer that would go with both ice creams. It didn't quite work out. It wasn't bad, but it just tasted bitter and the chocolate in the beer tasted weird (sorry but no more descriptive terms come to mind).
New Belgium Brewing Co. Belgian Stout - I chose this one specifically to go with chocolate ice cream. The idea was that a dark belgian beer should mix well with creamy chocolate ice cream. It worked!!! The ice cream brought out the best flavors of the beer and vice versa.
I still have a few more beers to try, but a person can only have so many beer floats on any given day. I don't even want to know what the calorie count of this adventure was!!!